Thursday, 4 June 2015

The Tantalizing Security Of Definite Answers


During the year I worked as a preschool teacher, I was taught that children find sanctuary in routine because it's always easy to anticipate what will happen next.

If you were raised in an Egyptian home like myself, chances are you hated the response "Insha'Allah" (God willing) whenever you asked your parents whether something in the future was going to happen, be it an outing or buying something new. You always yearned for a clear 'Yes' or 'No'.

Growing past childhood, our desire for clear answers is usually barely changed. The only difference is that it encompasses a wider array of matters. Questions about future plans, ideologies, beliefs, and existential thoughts engulf us, all pleading to be met with clear answers that leave no room for the bewilderment of doubt.

But much like a person lost at sea, we cling to the first form of a clear idea we come across, no matter how narrow minded, erroneous or incomplete it is. The thought of venturing back into that vast and dark sea of the unknown sends a shiver down our spines.

And before we know it, life is polarized into whites and blacks with a vast space of nothingness in between. Nothingness that either makes us scared, angry or defensive.

The Safety Net of Grey Areas


I believe that one has got to be a human being with purpose. Going with the flow does not mean you should be spineless or with no grounds to stand. I know how numbingly comfortable it is to know exactly where you're going. How confident it makes you to know every step you'll take, at least until you reach the horizon.

But are you even certain you'll live to see another day? Are you for a fact certain of anything?

No. And if you are, I hate to break it to you, but you'll face some really hard times ahead of you.

I don't like heartache, and unless you're a masochist, I don't think you do either. That's why my favorite strategy by far is bearing in mind that 'everything is a fifty-fifty chance.' For as long as you keep that in sight, you'll take whatever life throws at you with pleasure if it's good, or patience if it's bad.

It's much like how you never get disappointed if you never had expectations in the first place.

Weaving the Grey Bonds of Love and Understanding


The grey area is much more than just relief and acceptance for the life events that unfold. The grey area is where much of life happens, and where most of our emotions, hopes and fears lie as well.

It is this room where you feel confident enough to admit you've been wrong, and to venture back into the dark because you know it's the only way you can ever grow. You will do so knowing that chances are great you'll keep swimming for longer than you hope, and that you'll probably get exhausted along the way.

But it's like once you've opened up your mind and heart to the grey area, you can never tolerate the closing walls of definite blacks and whites. Because every time you look at them, all you see will be the greys that lead to either. Grey will be inevitable, and unlike how you thought it would be, accepting its uncertainty will be key to your inner peace.

I don't mean to come off as a wise ass, for I am as foolish as a king's jester pretends to be. But this much I know, that love brings me inner peace. And that I can't accept, let alone love myself or those around me if I fail or refuse to see and ponder the grey area.


It hurts me and greatly troubles me whenever I see people getting aggressive with one another over difference of opinion or perspective. This idea that there is only one right answer, and one right way to look at things has brought us nothing but hatred and an urge to hurt one another.

Life is in the here and now. Don't waste your time away swimming against the endless tides of 'what if.'

I don't know how many shades there are to grey, but I'm sure each one of them is unique and worth contemplating. Take it or leave it, but either way give it the respect it deserves.

8 comments:

  1. Like this, one might understand you turn the "grey area" and doubt into yet another absolute and unavoidable truth. In other words, we would be forced into an absolute doubt because there is no absolute yes and absolute no. What do you think?

    Hassan Abdelbaten

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One may possibly consider it that way, but I guess it also goes back to what you believe constitutes "truth". What I mean to say is, "absolute truth" is to a great extent unattainable given man's limited resources and knowledge; and maybe that's what makes doubt inevitable.

      It is good to seek as much knowledge as you can, but I don't think the amount of knowledge one can attain in a human lifetime will lead to absolute truths. Yet, we seek the most convincing and logical interpretations of truth that we can formulate based on the knowledge and experience we have.

      Does that makes sense?

      Delete
    2. It does make sense, in the particular thinking frame you have set for yourself. However, if it continues on the lines of your first explanation, it does not exactly address the point I raised.

      We seem to agree that we seek the clearest interpretations of truth. And neither me nor you have attained the absolute truth (far so), on that too I think we can agree. But that the absolute truth is "absolutely" unattainable (which is what I understood from what you said, despite the use of the tempering "to a great extent" -- what's the extent of an absolute? -- ), this is hard to know and goes back to the contradiction I try to outline.

      The problem in my view is not in "what we believe constitutes truth" but in:

      1/ The recursive aspect of truth: we need truth to find truths about truth (e.g. a question such as "is it true that we cannot attain truth?" holds a severe logical handicap, because we try to apply to the subject "truth" the predicate "true", while it depends on the subject).

      2/ More critically, the pervasive and contradictive nature of absoluteness in human thinking. One consequence: when trying to get rid of absolute thinking, one easily falls into another kind of absolute thinking (e.g. when we say "everything is relative", we cannot apply this rule to itself, it's contradictory).

      Hence my conclusion, and sorry to repeat myself: I don't think an absolute doubt is the correct answer to the problem of absolute truths. It is the natural consequence of absolutely suppressing the absolute truths: "doubt" simply becomes the new absolute truth (note the recursive aspect).

      H.A.

      Delete
    3. I see what you're getting at. But in the meantime, I believe that maybe this is a philosophical matter where more questions are raised than answers provided... which I often think is good.

      But being a journalist, I know that you can go on playing with words and tweaking ideas all day, and you still won't get to a particular destination.

      So if I were to apply the ideas and notions above to my life in simple words, I would just say that I'd rather be in doubt despite the little or abundant knowledge that I have in hopes that my thirst for knowledge would never get quenched, than label whatever knowledge I have as truth -absolute or not- and bury my curiosity for more knowledge... or even worse, grow an unhealthy ego that refuses to consider matters from a different perspective.

      Delete
    4. Playing with words? Tweaking ideas all day? Bury your curiosity? Grow an unhealthy ego? I honestly wonder from where all that came from. I like to believe, not from me. I also like to believe not from you. A third party then, maybe... And in the end, yet another absolute statement : I'd rather X than Y... I am not sure you really see what I was trying to get at. I am also not sure you tried to "consider matters from a different perspective".

      I had more to give on this, including what I think could have been few helpful advices from my little and limited experience, but I am not sure now this is what you are looking for at the moment.

      Still, I'm happy and honored I could talk to a journalist. I don't hold any degree and have no outstanding profession, but I would tend to believe this doesn't really matter for someone like you.

      Catch you later, Enas. Have a nice day.

      H.A.

      Delete
    5. I hadn't seen your last comment until today. By "I know that you can go on playing with words and tweaking ideas all day.." I meant "one" rather than "you". Apologies if that caused any misunderstanding, or if that put you in a defensive mode.

      However, whether or not you believe I did consider things from a different perspective, the fact remains all the same that I enjoy listening to different perspectives than mine, as long as they don't pose as personally offensive to me. You are certainly more than welcome to share yours, and I am glad we shared the brief conversation above.

      Have a good day, Hassan.

      Delete
    6. Re-reading this after almost a year helps putting things back into perspective. I did feel the need to defend myself although there wasn't any offense. My apologies for that.

      I too am glad we had this exchange.

      Sorry for the late reply. I was reminded of you while reading your recent article on Siwa and consumerism for madamasr. Or was that another Enas el Masry?

      Anyway. Please continue writing. It helps.

      Greetings,

      H.A.

      Delete
    7. That sure was me :)

      And guess what, I had an encounter a few months ago that challenged me to redefine my stance on grey areas and that sometimes they may be dangerous, too.
      It's always really refreshing to have someone challenge our strong held believes, and I'm grateful for any healthy challenge as such.

      It's good to hear back from you :) I wish you a splendid day.

      Delete